Space at a premium: France and South Africa players at close quarters last week.
Space at a premium: France and South Africa players at close quarters last week. Alamy Stock Photo

Numbers games: Are there too many players on the pitch in field sports?

Team sizes were decided more than a hundred years ago, when athletes were smaller and slower.

IRELAND’S SUCCESS AGAINST the Springboks will depend to a large degree on their ability to keep 15 players on the pitch. A difficult task against a team with an awesome scrum, who will accept every scrum penalty with another scrum penalty. 

Yellow cards feel inevitable, with Ireland’s best chance that South Africa infringe in different ways and have their own periods of 14 or 13 on duty. It feels like an unsatisfactory way to determine the better team; the officials’ interpretation of events pivotal to the outcome of games. But we won’t get into that particular to and fro. 

Numbers are on the mind this week. We’re hoping for 15 v 15 for 80 minutes to give us the best spectacle. But would it be an even better show if it was 14 v 14? Yes would seem the obvious answer. The evasion-to-collision ratio might alter to a degree where the game is better to watch, and play. 

But sports can be stuck in their ways. They will tweak rules frequently, but the essential components of how many are on a team, how big the pitch and goalposts are, tend to stay the same. 

The first rugby union internationals in the 1870s were 20 a-side, with 15 of them forwards, until they decided that was too busy and reduced the teams to 15 in 1877. Nearly 150 years later, another reduction is perhaps due. 

The same perhaps for soccer, which has been 11-a-side since 1897, but that number had been the convention for many years before it was standardised by the International Football Association Board. 

GAA teams went from 21 a side in the 1880s, to 17 in the next decade before it was set at 15 v 15 in 1913. 

The dimensions of the pitch and numbers on it have not changed since, but the players certainly have. The average Irish person is bigger, considerably. A year after hurling and football went to 15 a-side, the typical Irish man stood at 5ft 5in. He is now 5ft 10in. The average woman too has shot up from 5ft to 5ft 5in.

Brentford and Brighton players contest a corner. Brentford and Brighton players contest a corner. Alamy Stock Photo

Your intercounty player of 112 years ago may well have been bigger than average. They are for sure now. Add in the conditioning of modern athletes and you’re looking at a different set of specimens for whom these rules and numbers were devised. 

Even a casual viewer can see that a lot of the problems of modern sports are rooted in too many players being on the pitch, getting in each other’s way. 

Should we throw the ball out wide in rugby? Not much space, unless you are on the front foot. So to get on the front foot we must crash into each other, loads of times.

Why all the passing backward and sideways in soccer? The only space is back the field. Anybody receiving the ball in an advanced position does so under acute stress. 

Same goes for Gaelic football and increasingly hurling. There wasn’t room to swing a hurley during Thurles Sarsfields win over Inagh Kilnamona last weekend, and we got rucks and handpasses aplenty while forwards were brought back. 

Ballygunner have mastered the use of space, which is usually only really found in decent supply behind the ball carrier. They are a juggernaut as a result. The quality of viewing is not always through the roof, though this is not their fault. The most successful teams are often those who best adapt to the situation they are in. 

Pragmatism ought not be the priority for the administrators. But you’d feel that it is. Even suggesting reducing numbers in any sport would bring a lot of heat. In GAA you would be taking jerseys off lads, reducing access to the one and only sporting and social outlet in the parish, whether or not the parish takes up half a small city. 

Thurles Sarsfields and Inagh Kilnamona battle for possession. Thurles Sarsfields and Inagh Kilnamona battle for possession. Tom O'Hanlon / INPHO

In soccer you would be disturbing the equilibrium of the perfect global game, 11 v 11 a divine formula and the precise point of tension between defence and attack, instead of what was largely trial and error on the playing fields of Eton, when they weren’t playing the wall game or using leftovers to make new dessert dishes. Say what you will about the toffs of yesteryear, at least they were willing to try new things rather than serve up the same thing over and again. 

In rugby, a reduction to 14 or 13 would be met with – if you want that (and a lot of best things about rugby without many of the draggy parts) then migrate to League. This is Union, and we do collisions. And we do scrums! 

So things will stay as they are. But there must come a point where athletes are too big and too fast and the space too constrained as a result. Reducing the numbers would be far more practical than extending pitches, or stadiums.  

If nothing else, and if only to quieten uppity column writers and show them it is no use, it would be good to see the odd trial game in various codes: what it would look like with less bodies and more space. 

Who knows, like France against South Africa last week, there could be stages tonight at Lansdowne Road where yellow cards are in sync. You could view it as a live trial, or nature’s way of controlling the population.    

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
Submit a report
Please choose a reason for reporting this comment. Your report will be reviewed by our moderation team
We've received your report. Thank you for helping keep our community safe and respectful.

Leave a comment cancel

 
JournalTv
News in 60 seconds